← Back to the literature review

Visio-vestibular examination after pediatric concussion

Cerebro NeuroTech, Inc.Focused narrative review

Abstract

Following a concussion, a child may experience dizziness while shifting gaze between targets or difficulty tracking a moving object. Clinicians can elicit these findings at the bedside, but their interpretation depends on how the examination is administered and what the examiner records. We reviewed four publications addressing the clinical role, uptake, reproducibility, and discriminatory performance of visio-vestibular examination in children and adolescents.

Emergency department clinicians documented at least part of the examination in 64% of eligible encounters in one study. A separate study found fair to moderate agreement between examiners on individual maneuvers. In adolescent athletes, symptom provocation during four eye and head movement tasks showed its highest observed discrimination at a threshold of 20 repetitions.

Together, these studies support examining visual and vestibular function within a broader clinical assessment. They also identify a specific question for quantitative measurement: can an instrument capture reproducible information beyond the symptoms patients report and the signs clinicians observe?

Scope and approach

This narrative review examines four selected publications from 2019–2022: a retrospective implementation study, a prospective reliability study, a clinical review, and a cross-sectional comparison of injured and healthy athletes [1][2][3][4]. We compared populations, examination procedures, endpoints, and timing after injury. Selection was confined to these four papers. Their endpoints answer different questions, so we present results by study without pooling estimates. The clinical review provides context and contributes no additional participant cohort.

What the examination measures

Smooth pursuit asks the patient to follow a moving target. Saccades require rapid shifts of gaze between targets. Gaze stability tasks require the patient to maintain fixation while moving the head. Each task can produce distinct observations. A clinician may see the eyes lose the target, a patient may report dizziness, or both may occur. Near-point convergence adds another measure: the distance at which the patient reports double vision or the examiner observes loss of binocular alignment, depending on the procedure. The acute-care review places these observations alongside injury history, symptoms, cognition, balance, and the neurologic examination. Their clinical meaning depends on that wider assessment [3].

Who receives the examination in acute care?

Corwin and colleagues reviewed 400 emergency department encounters involving children aged 6–18 after clinicians received training and implementation support. Clinicians documented a vestibular and oculomotor examination in 64% of encounters and in 73% of patients ultimately diagnosed with concussion. The study counted a partially completed examination as completed. Conversely, an undocumented maneuver could have been performed. The estimate therefore describes documented uptake and leaves the proportion receiving a complete battery uncertain [1].

Examination use also varied with the clinical presentation. Among patients with a final diagnosis other than concussion, a nonsport injury, no concussion history, and two or fewer symptoms, 46% received the examination [1]. This matters when interpreting routine-care records. Patients with documented findings represent a selected portion of those evaluated, and a blank field cannot establish that a clinician tested the patient and found normal function.

How consistently do clinicians score the same patient?

A second emergency department study enrolled 155 patients aged 6–18 with head injury and involved 65 clinicians. The authors assessed agreement between different examiners in 112 patients and repeatability with the same examiner in 43. The median interval from injury to the first examination was 5.2 hours. Five of nine maneuvers showed moderate agreement between examiners, and the remainder showed fair agreement. With the same examiner, six of nine showed substantial agreement. The median interval between examinations was 35 minutes, which limits inference about measurements separated by days of recovery [2].

Smooth pursuit illustrates why the definition of an abnormal finding matters. Between-examiner agreement was 74% under the full scoring rule, with a chance-adjusted agreement statistic (Cohen’s κ) of 0.331. When the researchers counted symptom provocation alone, agreement rose to 94% (κ = 0.563) [2]. Removing an observational component changed what the test measured. Higher agreement under the narrower rule does not establish which rule better identifies concussion.

How much challenge is enough to provoke symptoms?

Storey and colleagues compared 69 adolescent athletes evaluated within 28 days of concussion with 69 athletes without recent concussion. Participants performed horizontal and vertical saccades and horizontal and vertical gaze stability tasks for up to 30 repetitions. The endpoint was the onset or worsening of symptoms. The investigators counted how many of the four tasks provoked symptoms by 10, 20, or 30 repetitions. Injured athletes were assessed a median of 10 days after injury (interquartile range, 5–15 days) [4].

For horizontal saccades, sensitivity rose from 25% by 10 repetitions to 50% by 20 and 69% by 30. At 30 repetitions, specificity fell across all four tasks as more healthy athletes reported symptoms. The four-task score had its highest observed area under the receiver operating characteristic curve at 20 repetitions (0.79, 95% confidence interval 0.72–0.85). At that repetition threshold, symptoms on at least one task identified 59% of injured athletes and yielded 96% specificity. Thus, approximately four in ten injured athletes had no positive task at that cutoff. The result describes a symptom-based score in this sample. It does not establish a universal repetition target or a diagnostic threshold for measured eye movements [4].

Interpretation and implications for quantitative assessment

The acute-care and athlete studies illuminate different stages of assessment. The emergency department reliability study examined whether clinicians agreed within hours of injury. The athlete study examined whether symptoms during standardized tasks distinguished groups, typically later after injury. Neither design establishes how a given child’s findings evolve between those time points. The publications also share investigators and a pediatric research network. Their applicability to independent sites, adults, and patients with other causes of dizziness remains uncertain [1][2][3][4].

For Cerebro NeuroTech, these findings motivate a testable hypothesis. Instrumented eye-movement measurements may add information to clinician observations and patient-reported symptoms when all three are collected during the same task. Testing that hypothesis requires preserving each observation separately, documenting the repetitions actually completed, and distinguishing a symptom-limited stop from loss of the tracking signal. Reporting the proportion of attempted sessions that yield usable measurements alongside performance in those sessions would make the result interpretable. None of the four publications evaluated a Cerebro device.

Conclusion

A bedside visio-vestibular finding is interpretable only in the context of the task performed, the response recorded, and the time since injury. These studies show that examiners can differ in scoring the same maneuver and that additional repetitions can elicit symptoms in both injured and healthy athletes. For digital assessment, the unresolved question is whether measuring the response directly improves reproducibility and contributes clinically meaningful information beyond the bedside examination.

References

  1. Corwin DJ, Propert KJ, Zorc JJ, Zonfrillo MR, Wiebe DJ. Use of the vestibular and oculomotor examination for concussion in a pediatric emergency department. American Journal of Emergency Medicine. 2019;37:1219–1223.
  2. Corwin DJ, Arbogast KB, Swann C, Haber R, Grady MF, Master CL. Reliability of the visio-vestibular examination for concussion among providers in a pediatric emergency department. American Journal of Emergency Medicine. 2020;38:1847–1853.
  3. Corwin DJ, Grady MF, Master CL, Joffe MD, Zonfrillo MR. Evaluation and management of pediatric concussion in the acute setting. Pediatric Emergency Care. 2021;37:371–379.
  4. Storey EP, Corwin DJ, McDonald CC, et al. Assessment of saccades and gaze stability in the diagnosis of pediatric concussion. Clinical Journal of Sport Medicine. 2022;32:108–113.